Try Valley
Put your outbound workflow to work.
Saniya Sood
Published:
Updated:
Published September 14, 2026 · Updated October 8, 2026
The answer up front: choose Valley when you want a qualified, researched campaign that runs through to replies on LinkedIn and email, with your approval on every send, from one seat at $199 a month (or $149 billed quarterly). Choose PhantomBuster when you need configurable extraction and LinkedIn automations that feed a sales process you already own, priced by execution hours from $56 a month on an annual term.
Disclosure: Valley makes one of the tools discussed here. Where another tool is the better fit for your motion, this page says so. Vendor facts were read from the vendors' own pages on the dates named next to them.
How we know this category: Valley runs outbound for 1,000+ LinkedIn accounts and has sent 30M+ messages.
Valley is an AI outbound platform that finds the people most likely to buy from you - from live buying signals, natural-language search, or your own lists - qualifies them against your ICP, researches each one, and sends personalized messages across email and LinkedIn that get 15-45% reply rates, against a category average of about 2%.
► Done comparing? Run the warm-signal motion on your own account, free for 7 days
PhantomBuster is a cloud automation library, not a campaign workspace: it scrapes and acts on LinkedIn, Sales Navigator, Google Maps, Instagram, X, Reddit and more, and hands the result to other tools. Rating terms and the seven-stage method are defined once on how Valley compares outbound tools, so this page spends its words on the differences that are specific to this vendor.
Three differences that decide it
1. Email is not a PhantomBuster channel
PhantomBuster's email credits (500 a month on Start, 2,500 on Grow, 10,000 on Scale per its pricing page) find addresses; they do not send mail. Outreach runs as LinkedIn messages, connection requests, likes and event invites, and the documented reply workflow routes replies into a CRM or an external AI step, where a person writes and sends the answer. A full email sequence means a second subscription such as Instantly, lemlist or Smartlead, plus the glue between them.
Valley sends LinkedIn and email from one campaign, and replies land in one inbox with the prospect's research attached. Email is an add-on on Starter and included from Plus.
2. You buy execution hours and slots, not a seat
Start is $69 a month, or $56 on an annual term, for five automation slots and 20 execution hours a month. Grow is $159 (or $128) for 15 slots and 80 hours; Scale is $439 (or $352) for 50 slots and 300 hours. Hours do not roll over, there are no automatic overages, and automations pause when the allowance runs out. The 14-day trial needs no card and caps exports at ten rows; the free plan after it gives 30 minutes a month. A support article dated the prices as current in May 2026.
That model rewards a team that knows exactly which Phantoms it will run and how long each takes. It punishes a founder who wants to try a new audience every week. Valley's seat does not meter the hours.
3. Who owns the campaign after the data leaves the automation
PhantomBuster's outbound workflows page now describes AI qualification filters, AI personalization and CRM connections (HubSpot, Salesforce, Pipedrive, Clay), and an MCP server is on every plan. What it does not describe is a cited, per-prospect research dossier or a writing style learned from your own messages: the AI credits add a line of context, and an operator still owns deduplication, suppression and the send. Its own blog recommends 15 to 25 connection requests a day and 60 to 100 a week, and reviewers report flagged accounts and Phantoms that break when LinkedIn changes.
Valley qualifies each person against your ICP, researches them with sources, drafts in your voice, and waits for your approval. One owner, one campaign, one record of who was contacted.
Pricing, read October 8, 2026
Plan | Price | What it includes | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
PhantomBuster Start | $69 a month, or $56 a month on an annual term ($672 a year) | 5 slots; 20 execution hours a month; 500 email credits; 10,000 AI credits; 1,000 URL-finder credits | |
PhantomBuster Grow | $159 a month, or $128 annual ($1,536 a year) | 15 slots; 80 hours; 2,500 email credits; 30,000 AI credits; 10,000 URL-finder credits | |
PhantomBuster Scale | $439 a month, or $352 annual ($4,224 a year) | 50 slots; 300 hours; 10,000 email credits; 90,000 AI credits; 20,000 URL-finder credits | |
Valley | Starter $199 a month, or $149 a month billed quarterly; Plus $299 or $249 quarterly; Growth $499. Per seat. | Plus adds 1,000 emails a month, priority Slack support and an onboarding call (optional add-ons on Starter); Growth adds $300 in monthly credits. 7-day free trial. | Valley pricing, read October 8, 2026 |
Add the email sender and any enrichment tool to the PhantomBuster column before comparing, and count the hours a person spends keeping the Phantoms running. The stack-cost guide prices the assembled version.
When to choose PhantomBuster
You need recurring datasets from many platforms (post engagers, group members, Google Maps listings, Sales Navigator searches) for several teams.
A sales process and a sender already exist, and you want automations that feed them through HubSpot, Salesforce, Pipedrive, Clay, Zapier, Make or n8n.
You want to pay by usage with no card on the trial, and your volume is predictable enough that execution hours will not run out mid-month.
Someone technical owns it. Reviewers praise the no-code setup and documentation and complain about uninformative errors and slow support when something breaks.
When to choose Valley
You want a smaller number of relevant conversations, not a bigger spreadsheet.
Email and LinkedIn belong in the same campaign with one suppression list.
You want to read the research behind a message and approve it before it goes.
Nobody on the team should be maintaining scrapers.
A test to run on both
Take the people who engaged with three industry posts last week. In PhantomBuster, extract them, deduplicate, qualify, and show where the records go and who sends the email. In Valley, import the same list and open five prospects: fit, sources, draft. Include one person who engaged with two posts and check that both tools contact them once. Then compare the time spent and, after two weeks, the replies against the benchmarks.
Give your sales team
an unfair advantage.
FAQ
Can PhantomBuster send cold email? No. Its email credits find addresses. Sending needs a connected tool such as Instantly, lemlist or Smartlead.
Is PhantomBuster safe for LinkedIn? Its own blog recommends 15 to 25 connection requests a day. Reviewers on Capterra (4.5 from 64) and Trustpilot (3.3 from 113) report flagged accounts and Phantoms that break; G2 blocked automated reads on October 8, 2026, so its score is not quoted.
What do you get free? A 14-day trial with no card, five slots, two execution hours, 50 email credits and exports capped at ten rows. After it, a free plan with one slot and 30 minutes a month.
Does PhantomBuster research prospects? AI credits add enrichment and personalization lines. It does not produce a cited open-web dossier per prospect, and it does not learn your writing style from your own messages.
Do execution hours roll over? No. Hours and credits reset monthly, there are no automatic overages, and automations pause when the allowance is used.
Sources
Vendor facts were read on October 8, 2026 unless a line says otherwise. Review sites that blocked automated reads are named as such rather than quoted. Send corrections through the contact options on this site with the vendor, the claim and the supporting page.
See also
Why B2B teams are replacing Clay, PhantomBuster and HeyReach with one tool
How Valley compares outbound tools: the method behind every vs page
How this page was made: the facts were read from the sources named in the text on October 8, 2026; drafted with AI assistance; fact-checked, reviewed and edited by Saniya Sood.
